Collins calls time on Genesis

Started by Pedro, September 17, 2010, 08:32:19 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Pedro

"Putting food on the table is more important than 7/8"

The Cosmic Lawnmower

Quote from: "D S"
Quote from: "turbo"still maybe this could leave the door open for good old pete to have another go, who knows.
Quite. Just because Phil can't drum (or sing  :twisted: ) anymore, it's rather conceited of him to say that is the end of Genesis.  It might be the end of Collins era Genesis but he was not the band - do Messrs Banks and Rutherford not get a say?!
Probably really unlikely to happen but (with will and diaries permitting) you potentially could still get a line-up of Gabriel, Banks, Rutherford, Hackett and Thompson as a very credible line-up to perform The Lamb, for example - which I'm sure many fans would prefer to another 2007 style reunion...

I agree and if Gabe won't do it get Ray Wilson back, he took (has taken) a lot of stick but I think he did a good job filling some big shoes.
Must say I would love to hear Bankser, Hackett & Rutherford playing together again.

MarkOneMusic

Quote from: "The Cosmic Lawnmower"Must say I would love to hear Bankser, Hackett & Rutherford playing together again.

Yes, I agree, that would be awesome!

MarkOneMusic

Quote from: "The Cosmic Lawnmower"Must say I would love to hear Bankser, Hackett & Rutherford playing together again.

Yes, I agree, that would be awesome!

Pajter

Quote from: "Pedro"Quite right, bands can carry on without key personnel....just look at Yes....

*takes cover behind the sofa....  :twisted:

And Dream Theater! :lol:

MrBabou

Quote from: "MarkOneMusic"
Quote from: "The Cosmic Lawnmower"Must say I would love to hear Bankser, Hackett & Rutherford playing together again.

Yes, I agree, that would be awesome!
They could be called Mike and the Bank Hackers...

Nah... cheezy...

 :mrgreen:
"The mind is like a parachute: it works best when it\'s open"... Frank Zappa

Neilgwhite

Quote from: "D S"
Quote from: "turbo"still maybe this could leave the door open for good old pete to have another go, who knows.
Quite. Just because Phil can't drum (or sing  :twisted: ) anymore, it's rather conceited of him to say that is the end of Genesis.  It might be the end of Collins era Genesis but he was not the band - do Messrs Banks and Rutherford not get a say?!
Probably really unlikely to happen but (with will and diaries permitting) you potentially could still get a line-up of Gabriel, Banks, Rutherford, Hackett and Thompson as a very credible line-up to perform The Lamb, for example - which I'm sure many fans would prefer to another 2007 style reunion...


Now i've dribbled all down my clean t-shirt.... Sounds like a job for Justin Lee Collins...
Hello, is there anybody in there?............